30 STORE BOUGHT CONDIMENTS: SHELF LIFE, STORAGE, & MORE
Have you ever wondered how long you should keep some of the condiments you are using for your charcuterie boards or sandwiches? Are you curious whether the "use by" date is accurate or just a sneaky way to get you to buy more? Below is a comprehensive list of the most common sauces, dressings, and relishes used to make charcuterie boards, sandwiches, etc and best practices for their storage before and after they have been opened.
While I don't recommend ignoring the "use by" dates, this might be a useful reference when you are on the fence about throwing something out.
Soy Sauce
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place, like a pantry.
After Opening: Refrigerate to maintain flavor and prevent mold growth.
Shelf Life
Unopened: 2-3 years.
Opened: Up to 1 year refrigerated.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration after opening is key.
Ketchup
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
After Opening: Refrigerate.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 1-2 years.
Opened: 4-6 months refrigerated.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration after opening.
Hot Sauce
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
After Opening: Most hot sauces can be stored at room temperature, but
refrigeration can help maintain color and flavor, especially for those with low vinegar
content.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 2-3 years.
Opened: 6 months to 1 year, depending on the type and ingredients. High-vinegar
sauces last longer.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration, especially for sauces with lower acidity.
Butter
Before Opening: Refrigerate or freeze
After Opening: Refrigerate.
Shelf Life:
Refrigerated: 1-3 months.
Frozen: 609 months
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration or freezing
Peanut Butter
Before Opening: Store in cool, dark place.
After Opening: Store in cool dark place or refrigerate (refrigeration is recommended
for natural peanut butter).
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 6-24 months. Seriously? Does anyone's peanut butter really last that long? I am pretty sure we've never had to concern ourselves with a shelf life of peanut butter.
Opened: 2-3 months at room temperature, 6-8 months (refrigeration is
recommended for natural peanut butter).
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration, especially for natural peanut butter.
White Vinegar
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
After Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
Shelf Life: Indefinite.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Tightly seal the container.
Balsamic Vinegar
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark Place.
After Opening: Store in cool, dark place.
Shelf Life: Indefinite, though quality may degrade after several years.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Tightly seal container.
Olive Oil
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
After Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 18-24 months.
Opened: 6-12 months.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Store in a dark glass bottle and avoid exposure to heat,
light, and air.
Sugar (Granulated)
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
After Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
Shelf Life: Indefinite, if kept dry.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Keep dry and in airtight container.
Salt
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
After Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
Shelf Life: Indefinite.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Keep dry.
Maple Syrup
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
After Opening: Refrigerate.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: Indefinite.
Opened: About 1 year refrigerated.Prolonging The Shelf Life:: Refrigerate after
opening.

Jalapeño Peppers in a Jar (Pickled)
Olive Tapenade
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place, or refrigerate depending on the product
Olives (Jarred)
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Pickles
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.
Cornichons (Small Pickles)
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Pesto
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place, or refrigerate depending on the productDijon Mustard
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Honey Mustard
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Grainy Mustard
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Fruit Chutney
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Pepper Jelly
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Cranberry Sauce (Jarred)
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Fruit Preserves (Jams, Jellies)
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dark place.Hummus
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
After Opening: Refrigerate immediately.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: Varies depending on the brand and type (check the package).
Opened: About 1 week refrigerated.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigerate promptly after opening.Store in an airtight
container to minimize exposure to air.If the top of the hummus is exposed to air, a
thin layer of olive oil can help prevent oxidation and spoilage.
Barbecue Sauce
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
After Opening: Refrigerate.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 1-2 years.
Opened: 6-12 months refrigerated.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration after opening.
Ranch Dressing
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
After Opening: Refrigerate.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 1-2 years.
Opened: 1-2 months refrigerated.
Prolonging Shelf Life: Refrigeration after opening.
Blue Cheese Dressing
Before Opening: Store in a cool, dry place.
After Opening: Refrigerate.
Shelf Life:
Unopened: 1-2 years.
Opened: 1-2 months refrigerated.Prolonging
Shelf Life: Refrigeration after opening.
Honey
Before Opening: Store at room temperature in a tightly sealed container.








Leave a comment
Also in BOARD BITES
A Stress-Free Feast: Why a Charcuterie Board Thanksgiving is the Perfect Solution
By Michele Parkinson November 04, 2025
The charcuterie concept is inherently communal, making it the perfect low-stress potluck. Instead of asking Aunt Carol to bring "a side dish," ask her to be in charge of a board.
Continue reading
Easy Cranberry Sauce
By Michele Parkinson November 04, 2025
If you have never made homemade cranberry sauce you just haven't lived. Yes the pre-made is fine but the homemade is far better and it isn't even hard to do!
Continue reading
Turkey, Brie, & Cranberry Crostini
By Michele Parkinson November 04, 2025
This appetizer captures all the classic flavors of Thanksgiving in one elegant, bite-sized package. It’s perfect for using up holiday leftovers or serving as part of your Thanksgiving charcuterie board.
Continue reading